In Lancaster, PA, Sporting dropped a tough result against Hofstra in the playoffs. Throughout the game, Sporting dominated the game, but went behind when Hofstra converted a penalty given in Hofstra's first chance of the game. However, Sporting fought back and Nicky Schwab equalized with an excellent solo effort. Sporting nearly stole the game in the last minutes, but were thwarted by some terrific goalkeeping from Hofstra. The game then went to penalties, and Hostra held their nerves for the shootout victory to move on to the final. The game marked the end for graduating seniors Al Licata, Brad Boehringer, Anders Hilton, Jake Hostetler, Diego Fiamma, Matt Halvorson, and Matt Liponis. It was a disappointing end to the season for Sporting Carlisle, but it was nonetheless an extremely successful season that surpassed all expectations for the team.